LambeauLeap1250 WSSP


Test
  
Go to page Previous  1, 2  [ 39 posts ]  New Topic   Add Reply

BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting closed.

Author Message
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting closed
#21

Posted: February 28, 2020, 7:51 AM Post
Posts: 16
1.ESmall--SEC dominant and has a pathway to the bigs
2.DRassmussen--boom or bust but the boom could be big and really soon
3.Feliciano--looking forward to 7 years of catching under control
4.Turang--good looking kid, could be drafted over/traded over soon
5.AKelly--boom or bust but not really soon
6.Lazar--youngest of the “Dudes” or righty starters that don’t light up the radar gun but move up the system with some decent stats/peripherals
7.Alec Bett--a dude, Ross Stripling MLB comparison would be nice.
8.AAshby--interesting player based on name, position of need, and stuff
9.BWahl--man among boys especially when you look at all the RMV teens.
10.EGarcia--projectable
11.Sunitch- lhp with nice WHIP
12.DFile--Dude.
13.CAndrews--I like him as a LHP that has great numbers. Competitor and I want him to do well.
14.Kahle--young catcher highly drafted and has some room to jump up the system.
15.Hummel--continues to thump.
16.BFrancis--Dude.
17.Zavolas--Dude.
18.Carlos Rodriguez--decent year and that is rare amongst our int’l teens.
19.Zhao--a rare long play for me based on spin rate
20.Devin Williams-talent but not a real prospect anymore. He is what he is but that could be decent…the dividing line in my mind. Everyone below has a flaw, is losing their star luster, or unproven to a point of being a lottery ticket. Above are the ones that have a chance to be as good as Devin could have been out of St Louis getting drafted with the top pick all those years ago.
21.JP Feyereisen- has some stuff but can he make a splash AND stay around the 26 man roster. Came a little too easily to us; I want to see the catch.
22.JJarvis--too young to know but size and comes from good baseball area in NC
23.NBennett - upside lefty that is 22 and poised to jump quickly
24.QTC--personal fav but has to rebound from injury
25.PHenry--holes in game but position of need; could be the Brady Quinn of mlb catchers


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#22

Posted: February 28, 2020, 11:03 AM Post
Posts: 96
Top-40
Tier 1
None
Tier 2
1 Ethan Small SP
Tier 3
2 Brice Turang SS
3 Drew Rasmussen SP
Tier 4
4 Aaron Ashby SP
5 Trey Supak SP
Tier 5
6 Max Lazar SP
7 Antoine Kelly SP
8 Mario Feliciano C
9 Zack Brown SP
10 Tristen Lutz OF
11 Carlos Rodriguez OF
12 Nick Bennett SP
13 Devin Williams RP
14 Corey Ray OF
15 Eduardo Garcia SS
Tier 6
16 Braden Webb SP
17 Lucas Erceg 3B
18 Thomas Dillard OF
19 Jacob Nottingham C
20 Felix Valerio 2B
21 Clayton Andrews RP
22 Micah Bello OF
23 JP Feyereisen RP
24 Quintin Torres-Costa RP
25 David Fry C
26 Luke Barker RP
27 Miguel Sanchez RP
28 Phil Bickford RP
Tier 7
29 Tyrone Taylor OF
30 Luis Medina OF
31 Bobby Wahl RP
32 Thomas Jankins SP
33 Alec Bettinger SP
34 Bowden Francis SP
35 Joantgel Segovia OF
36 Payton Henry C
37 Noah Zavolas SP
38 Nick Kahle C
39 Caden Lemons SP
40 Cooper Hummel OF


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#23

Posted: February 28, 2020, 11:56 AM Post
Posts: 26
Location: Dubuque, IA
ctmyers said:
Top-40
Tier 1
None
Tier 2
1 Ethan Small SP
Tier 3
2 Brice Turang SS
3 Drew Rasmussen SP
Tier 4
4 Aaron Ashby SP
5 Trey Supak SP
Tier 5
6 Max Lazar SP
7 Antoine Kelly SP
8 Mario Feliciano C
9 Zack Brown SP
10 Tristen Lutz OF
11 Carlos Rodriguez OF
12 Nick Bennett SP
13 Devin Williams RP
14 Corey Ray OF
15 Eduardo Garcia SS
Tier 6
16 Braden Webb SP
17 Lucas Erceg 3B
18 Thomas Dillard OF
19 Jacob Nottingham C
20 Felix Valerio 2B
21 Clayton Andrews RP
22 Micah Bello OF
23 JP Feyereisen RP
24 Quintin Torres-Costa RP
25 David Fry C
26 Luke Barker RP
27 Miguel Sanchez RP
28 Phil Bickford RP
Tier 7
29 Tyrone Taylor OF
30 Luis Medina OF
31 Bobby Wahl RP
32 Thomas Jankins SP
33 Alec Bettinger SP
34 Bowden Francis SP
35 Joantgel Segovia OF
36 Payton Henry C
37 Noah Zavolas SP
38 Nick Kahle C
39 Caden Lemons SP
40 Cooper Hummel OF



What do your tiers mean?


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#24

Posted: February 28, 2020, 1:13 PM Post
Posts: 96
ARobsBrewCrew said:
Top-40

What do your tiers mean?


Tier 1: Perennial All-Star (this would have included Hiura if not for graduation)
Tier 2: Potential All-Star/Above average ML regular
Tier 3: Above average/Solid ML regular, but below All-Star level
Tier 4: Average/Below average ML regular
Tier 5: Good chance to be ML contributor, but work to do
Tier 6: Decent chance to be ML contributor/bench role
Tier 7: Potential for ML bench role, but most likely organizational soldier


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#25

Posted: February 28, 2020, 4:33 PM Post
Posts: 67
1. Hedbert Perez
2. Brice Turang
3. Tristan Lutz
4. Eduardo Garcia
5. Aaron Ashby
6. Drew Rasmussen
7. Antoine Kelly
8. Ethan Small
9. Mario Feliciano
10. Jesus Parra
11. Trey Supak
12. Carlos Rodriguez
13. Payton Henry
14. Luis Medina
15. Devin Williams
16. Zack Brown
17. Corey Ray
18. Dylan File
19. Nick Bennett
20. Thomas Dillard
21. Micah Bello
22. Jacob Nottingham
23. Lucas Erceg
24. Max Lazar
25. Justin Jarvis
26. Bobby Wahl
27. Joe Gray
28. Jeferson Quero
29. Pablo Abreu
30. Lun Zhao


I'll be that "guy" with my #1 spec.


Last edited by Manty Brewer Fan on March 09, 2020, 7:50 AM, edited 1 time in total.

 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#26

Posted: February 28, 2020, 9:02 PM Post
Posts: 616
Location: Milwaukee
1 Turang
2 E. Small
3 A.Ashby
4 Supak
5 Lutz
6 M.Feliciano
7 D. Rasmussen
8 A. Kelly
9 Ray
10 Z. Brown
11 D. Williams
12 Nottingham
13 Carlos Rodriguez
14 B.Webb
15 D.File
16 M. Bello
17 N. Zavolas
18 Nick Bennett
19 P. Henry
20 N. Kahle
21 Bowden Francis
22 Perdomo
23 Bettinger
24 J.Gray Jr
25 Max Lazar
26 T. Dillard
27 Erceg
28 C. Lemons
29 K. Howell
30 Wahl


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#27

Posted: February 29, 2020, 7:19 PM Post
Posts: 99
Location: Portland, OR
1. Tristen Lutz
2. Brice Turang
3. Ethan Small
4. Aaron Ashby
5. Mario Feliciano
6. Antoine Kelly
7. Trey Supak
8. Drew Rasmussen
9. Luis Medina
10. Payton Henry
11. Micah Bello
12. Gabe Holt
13. Carlos Roa
14. Nick Bennett
15. Hedbert Perez
16. Joe Gray
17. Phil Bickford
18. Max Lazar
19. Bowden Francis
20. Eduardo Garcia
21. Felix Valerio
22. Noah Zavolas
23. Dylan File
24. Alec Bettinger
25. Carlos Rodriguez

26. Jake Gatewood
27. Pablo Abreu
28. Justin Jarvis
29. Branlyn Jaraba
30. Erys Bautista


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#28

Posted: March 01, 2020, 1:47 AM Post
Posts: 2866
1. Ethan Small LHP
2. Brice Turang SS
3. Tristen Lutz RF
4. Aaron Ashby LHP
5. Drew Rasmussen RHRP
6. Mario Feliciano C
7. Hedbert Perez OF (the hottest name in all of baseball it seems)
8. Eduardo Garcia SS
9. Luis Medina OF
10. Dylan File RHP
11. Antoine Kelly LHRP
12. Thomas Dillard 1B
13. Max Lazar RHP
14. Trey Supak RHP
15. Carlos Rodriguez CF
16. Bowden Francis RHP
17. Nick Bennett LHP
18. Payton Henry C
19. Corey Ray OF
20. Felix Valerio 2B
21. Jesus Parra 3B
22. Micah Bello OF
23. Alec Bettinger RHP
24. Justin Jarvis RHP
25. Cooper Hummel LF (you are welcome Clancy)

HM. Noah Zavolas RHP
HM. Je'Von Ward OF (I think 2021 is his year)
HM. Caden Lemons RHP (Get Healthy)
HM. Joe Gray OF
HM. Gabe Holt 2B (only if he can return to 2B)

Shout out to Luke Barker RHRP. Win a BP spot!!! (I just like him)

If you haven't noticed I like age appropriate athletes who haven't hit a wall in their development yet. I do not think relievers are top 25 worthy unless I see them being special. I believe most MLB relievers are MiLB starters who faltered on their path to develop a starters pitch mix. IE: Bettinger and Francis are more likely to be relievers at the MLB level than Andrews Devin Wahl etc. All in all I really like the MKE farm system even if it's not regarded well by the pundits. There's a lot of lottery ticket type position players and advanced quality arms in this system. You don't need to hit them all, you need to hit a few real well. The athletes they have piled up in the OF is quite absurd.

PS: Tell me if I missed something obvious.


Last edited by TJseven7 on March 04, 2020, 5:22 PM, edited 2 times in total.

 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#29

Posted: March 01, 2020, 2:46 PM Post
Posts: 2335
Location: Madison, WI
1. SS/2B-Brice Turang
2. LHP-Ethan Small
3. OF-Tristen Lutz
4. CF-Corey Ray
5. LHP-Aaron Ashby
6. C/DH-Mario Feliciano
7. RHP-Zack Brown
8. SS-Eduardo Garcia
9. LHP-Antoine Kelly
10. RHP-Drew Rasmussen
11. OF-Carlos Rodriguez
12. RHP-Trey Supak
13. RHP-Devin Williams
14. C-Payton Henry
15. OF-Luis Medina
16. CF-Joe Gray
17. C/LF-Nick Kahle
18. OF-Micah Bello
19. OF-Hedbert Perez
20. RHP-Alec Bettinger
21. 1B/LF-Thomas Dillard
22. RHP-Bobby Wahl
23. RHP-Max Lazar
24. RHP-Dylan File
25. RHP-Noah Zavolas


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#30

Posted: March 01, 2020, 7:29 PM Post
User avatar
Posts: 6932
wildcat2237 said:
13. Max Lazar: Low ceiling. Suter part 2?

So far, Lazar has a much higher K rate than Suter did.

Lazar's K rate at A-ball last year was very similar to Mike Fiers (12.4 for Lazar, 12.0 for Fiers, 8.4 for Suter), if you're looking for a high 80's FB comp.


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#31

Posted: March 02, 2020, 12:19 AM Post
Posts: 799
LouisEly said:
wildcat2237 said:
13. Max Lazar: Low ceiling. Suter part 2?

So far, Lazar has a much higher K rate than Suter did.

Lazar's K rate at A-ball last year was very similar to Mike Fiers (12.4 for Lazar, 12.0 for Fiers, 8.4 for Suter), if you're looking for a high 80's FB comp.


I'm pretty sure Fiers was always a 91-94 guy in the minors.

It is just really really tuff to be a successful big league right hander throwing 87-88. I hope I am wrong on Lazar.


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#32

Posted: March 02, 2020, 7:23 AM Post
Posts: 956
wildcat2237 said:
LouisEly said:
wildcat2237 said:
13. Max Lazar: Low ceiling. Suter part 2?

So far, Lazar has a much higher K rate than Suter did.

Lazar's K rate at A-ball last year was very similar to Mike Fiers (12.4 for Lazar, 12.0 for Fiers, 8.4 for Suter), if you're looking for a high 80's FB comp.


I'm pretty sure Fiers was always a 91-94 guy in the minors.

It is just really really tuff to be a successful big league right hander throwing 87-88. I hope I am wrong on Lazar.

6'3" 185 can turn into 6'3" 200 pretty quickly. A little added muscle and weight can add speed and endurance. Not saying it happened, but I am sure he is doing everything he can to improve.


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#33

Posted: March 02, 2020, 7:55 AM Post
Posts: 557
LouisEly said:
wildcat2237 said:
13. Max Lazar: Low ceiling. Suter part 2?

So far, Lazar has a much higher K rate than Suter did.

Lazar's K rate at A-ball last year was very similar to Mike Fiers (12.4 for Lazar, 12.0 for Fiers, 8.4 for Suter), if you're looking for a high 80's FB comp.


I know he didn’t come up in the Brewers system, but what about Davies as a comp?


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#34

Posted: March 02, 2020, 10:27 AM Post
Posts: 96
wildcat2237 said:
LouisEly said:
wildcat2237 said:
13. Max Lazar: Low ceiling. Suter part 2?

So far, Lazar has a much higher K rate than Suter did.

Lazar's K rate at A-ball last year was very similar to Mike Fiers (12.4 for Lazar, 12.0 for Fiers, 8.4 for Suter), if you're looking for a high 80's FB comp.


I'm pretty sure Fiers was always a 91-94 guy in the minors.

It is just really really tuff to be a successful big league right hander throwing 87-88. I hope I am wrong on Lazar.


Because Fiers was 24 when he was drafted, it's hard to make apples to apples comparisons between the two. Lazar can throw harder than 87-88, though. He can run it up mid-low 90's easily, but stays high 80's because of how well the fastball plays (particularly up). It's just about getting command consistency with his breaking pitches, which are already very good. And, as previously mentioned, being 20 years old and weighing probably 170 pounds leaves a ton of room for projectability. Davies nor Fiers had that high of a ceiling, imo. I liken him more to Freddy Peralta at a similar age, but with much better control.


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#35

Posted: March 02, 2020, 2:06 PM Post
User avatar
Global Moderator
Posts: 13040
1. Ethan Small LHP
2. Brice Turang SS
3. Drew Rasmussen RHRP
4. Aaron Ashby LHP
5. Tristen Lutz RF
6. Mario Feliciano C
7. Antoine Kelly LHRP
8. Dylan File RHP
9. Eduardo Garcia SS
10. Luis Medina OF
11. Hedbert Perez
12. Corey Ray OF
13. Thomas Dillard 1B
14. Max Lazar RHP
15. Trey Supak RHP
16. Alec Bettinger RHP
17. Carlos Rodriguez CF
18. Bowden Francis RHP
19. Nick Bennett LHP
20. Felix Valerio 2B
21. Jesus Parra 3B
22. Micah Bello OF
23. Payton Henry C
24. Je’Von Ward OF
25. Caden Lemons RHP

"Dustin Pedroia doesn't have the strength or bat speed to hit major-league pitching consistently, and he has no power......He probably has a future as a backup infielder if he can stop rolling over to third base and shortstop." Keith Law, 2006


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#36

Posted: March 07, 2020, 6:39 AM Post
Posts: 4
1;E. SMALL/ LHP
2;D.RASMUSSEN / RHP
3;M. FELICIANO /C
4; B.TURANG /IF
5; Z. BROWN /RHP
6;A. ASHBY /LHP
7;H. PEREZ / OF
8; E. GARCIA/IF
9; T. LUTZ /OF
10;C. RODRIGUEZ /OF
11;L. MEDINA /OF
12;L. ERCEG /IF
13; C.RAY /OF
14; T.SUPAK /RHP
15; D. WILLIAMS/ RHP
16;A.PERDOMO /LHP
17;J. WARD /OF
18;K.HOWELL/ IF
19;A. KELLY/LHP
20;P. BICKFORD/RHP
21;A. BETTINGER/ RHP
22;P. HENRY/C
23;B.FRANCIS/RHP
24; C.SPANBERGER/OF
25;B.WEBB/RHP

26;D.FILE/RHP
27;J.P.FEYEREISEN /RHP
28;J.SEGOVIA /OF
29;Q.TORRES-COSTA/ LHP
30;T. TAYLOR /OF


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting is open
#37

Posted: March 07, 2020, 9:01 AM Post
Posts: 2281
1. B. Turang
2. T. Lutz
3. A. Ashby
4. M. Feliciano
5. D. Rasmussen
6. E. Small
7. C. Ray
8. Z. Brown
9. A. Kelly
10. T. Supek
11. J. Nottingham
12. J Gray
13. L. Erceg
14. D. Williams
15. E. Garcia
16. P. Henry
17. H.Perez
18. C. Rodriquez
19. B. Webb
20. M. Bello
21. M. Lazar
22. P. Bickford
23. J. Ward
24. T. Dillard
25. D. File


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - LAST DAY TO VOTE!!!
#38

Posted: March 18, 2020, 10:01 PM Post
User avatar
Global Moderator
Posts: 3161
First of all, thank you reilly for putting this all together again & thank you also to everyone who took time to post their rankings.

Obviously baseball prospects are probably not most people's top priorities right now, but with that said here is my list & I hope we all get to read about these guys & their teammates in the link reports soon...

01. Brice Turang
02. Ethan Small
03. Drew Rasmussen
04. Aaron Ashby
05. Alec Bettinger
06. Antoine Kelly
07. Mario Feliciano
08. Tristen Lutz
09. Eduardo Garcia
10. Hedbert Perez
11. Clayton Andrews
12. Trey Supak
13. Corey Ray
14. Devin Williams
15. Zack Brown
16. Bowden Francis
17. Jacob Nottingham
18. Max Lazar
19. Dylan File
20. Noah Zavolas
21. Payton Henry
22. Luis Medina
23. Carlos Rodriguez
24. Joe Gray Jr.
25. Micah Bello


 Top
 
Offline  Re: BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects - 2020 Pre-Season Edition - Voting extended through March 26
#39

Posted: March 19, 2020, 7:05 AM Post
User avatar
Global Moderator
Posts: 7554
Voting is now closed. Watch for final results within the week.

Thanks to everyone who participated.


 Top
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Go to page Previous  1, 2  [ 39 posts ]  New Topic   Add Reply
Test
  


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Search this forum (phpBB search):
Jump to:  
Search entire board (Google search):
Google
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
Test